Thor vs. New Gods: Bruce Timm’s Perspective on Jack Kirby’s Career Peaks Sparks Controversy

Thor in Marvel Comics

Speaking with The Jack Kirby Collector, Timm opened up about why he liked drawing so many characters that are created by Jack Kirby wailing on Thor. This stems from a preference that Kevin Alteri, the director that Timm was working with at the time, had when it came to the character.

Bruce Timm prefers the New Gods to Thor

New Gods, drawn by Alex Ross

Timm and Alteri got into a debate about who was the better inker for Jack Kirby, which spiraled into the conversation that led Bruce Timm to pit so many characters made by Kirby against Thor. He said:

“Kevin Alteri, the director, was going on at one point saying how he thought that Thor was the peak of Jack’s career. I was like, “Yeah, Thor is really, really good, but there’s something really great about those New Gods comics.” Kevin was like, “New Gods is nothing compared to Thor. They’re not really as good.””

Timm would go on to exclusively draw other Kirby characters like the Silver Surfer and Orion going ham on Thor, which sort of became a running meme for the creator. The creator continued:

On one hand, yeah, they’re not quite as perfect as the Thor comics but they’re great to look at. You can’t beat that Royer inking! He’s like, “Nah, the Colletta stuff is the best.” He was actually saying that. So I did this one drawing of Orion beating up on Thor, and I inked Thor “Colletta style” and I inked Orion “Royer style,” and that was the first drawing I did.

It is heartwarming to see that even comic book legends engage in everyday fandom stuff like normal fanboys do. But Timm also made it clear that he actually does not have a thing against Thor.

Bruce Timm actually enjoys Thor Comics

Chris Hemsworth as Thor

Bruce Timm clarified in the same interview that he does not have anything against Thor, and said that he actually enjoys Thor comics a lot.

While there are a lot of similarities between Orion and Thor (so much so that the characters were fused together to create Thorion for the Amalgam Universe), one can see how Timm’s adoration for one set of characters could bleed into that of another when it came to Jack Kirby’s work. Timm said:

“I basically ended up doing a whole series of all these other Kirby characters beating up on Thor because that was Kevin’s favorite character. That’s all it was about; I have nothing against Thor. I love the Thor comics.”

Thor as a character holds many of the hallmarks of characters that Jack Kirby loved depicting in his work. His work with New Gods, Inhumans, Eternals, and Thor has a similar thread that goes through them, something that shines through in the stories that he tells, like a series of tropes that he loved coming back to again and again.

Related Posts

Ron Dean dead: Risky Business and The Breakfast Club star dies as wife pays tribute

Ron Dean – famous for starring in Risky Business and The Breakfast Club – has died at the age of 87, with his partner announcing the sad…

Susanna Reid clashes with Reform’s Nadine Dorries over Lucy Connolly in furious row on air

Susanna Reid clashed with Nadine Dorries on Wednesday’s edition of Good Morning Britain over in a debate over Lucy Connolly and Ed Balls even tried to diffuse…

“1 MIN AGO: Meghan Markle’s Children Officially REMOVED From Royal Succession — A Decision That Shakes the Monarchy to Its Core”

“1 MIN AGO: Meghan Markle’s Children Officially REMOVED From Royal Succession — A Decision That Shakes the Monarchy to Its Core” In a move no one saw…

THE FORGOTTEN PIANO – A ROYAL LOVE STORY! SURPRISINGLY SWEET: Kensington Palace insiders have revealed a moment so tender it feels straight out of a fairytale… One quiet evening, Prince William sat down at the Palace’s old piano – the very same one Kate used to practice on as a little girl. At first, he played clumsily, laughing at himself as the notes stumbled… but then, to Kate’s shock, he began to sing softly: “You’ll always be my Queen.” Witnesses say Kate’s eyes filled with tears as she listened. Smiling through the emotion, she gently whispered back: “You’re already my King.” No crowns. No cameras. Just a husband and wife, reminding each other that their love is stronger than titles, palaces, or duty

The Forgotten Piano: Prince William’s Serenade That Left Kate in Tears Royal watchers are reeling after  Kensington Palace insiders revealed an unthinkably romantic moment between Prince William and Princess Kate —…

ROYALS IN SH0CK! Catherine’s Midnight BOMBSHELL MESSAGE After William and King Charles’ Urgent Meeting At Balmoral STUNS the Palace – Everyone Left SPEECHLESS 😱👇👇

In a week marked by royal intrigue and family tensions, the Princess of Wales, Catherine, has once again captured hearts with a poignant Instagram post championing early…

Inside Victoria and David Beckham’s lavish homes as documentary shows insight into properties

Netflix’s Victoria Beckham documentary is now available to stream and while the Spice Girls star opens up about her life and career, we also get a glimpse…