It Looks Bleak: The Beatles Are Still Charting the Future of Pop, where no golden goose need ever stop laying

The Beatles Are Still Charting the Future of Pop. It Looks Bleak.

Their latest song points toward a future where no golden goose need ever stop laying.

Earlier this month, alongside the arrival of a new Beatles single called “Now and Then,” there also came a 12 minute and 24 second promotional film — exactly three times as long as the song itself — explaining the project. Why so long a preface? Part of it was the solemnity of the occasion: This was, the film’s title card proclaimed, “the last Beatles song.” But there was another purpose, too, one that was uncomfortably hard to miss.

“Now and Then” requires not just explanation but also, awkwardly, justification. The song was originally a demo recorded by John Lennon in his New York apartment in the late 1970s, well after the Beatles broke up. In the 1990s, it was among the recordings that Yoko Ono provided to Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr as candidates for being polished up into fully arranged songs. Two of those — “Free as a Bird” and “Real Love” — were released in the mid-1990s, as part of the “Anthology” series of TV documentaries, compilation albums and a book. But “Now and Then” was abandoned, in part because of technical difficulties in separating Lennon’s vocals from the murky piano on the same audio track: This was the audio equivalent of a scribbled note to self, not a usable studio recording. Decades later, though, in the course of making the 2021 documentary “Get Back,” the director Peter Jackson’s production company developed a cutting-edge machine-learning application that could be trained to tease apart components of recordings. Suddenly it was possible to isolate individual Beatles’ voices from garbled footage of them in studios and rehearsal halls as they conceived and recorded the album “Let It Be.” Applied to “Now and Then,” this new technology set Lennon’s singing free.

The moment when the promotional video evokes this jailbreak — playing Lennon’s isolated voice over footage that juxtaposes his face with an empty studio — is admittedly chills-inducing. The video is full of similar juxtapositions. We see the astonishingly well-preserved Paul McCartney of 2023, marveling at the gifts of technology; then we see him in the ’90s, goofing around with a still-alive George Harrison; then the bearded family man of the late ’60s, then the fresh-faced Liverpudlian lad suddenly catapulted to stardom. Time collapses: Beatles past and present, “now” and “then,” come together, Lennon’s voice from the ’70s layering with Harrison’s contributions from the ’90s “Anthology” sessions, McCartney and Starr’s more recent efforts, even scraps of wordless harmony singing borrowed from ’60s recording sessions and tracks like “Eleanor Rigby” and “Because.”

It’s so moving that it took me a few rewatches, over a few days, to start asking the obvious questions. Centrally: Does it really make sense to use a song originally written by Lennon alone, with no known intention of ever bringing it to his former bandmates, as the basis for a “Beatles” song? Is Lennon’s vocal, plucked and scrubbed by artificial intelligence and taking on a faintly unnatural air, something he would have embraced or been repulsed by? “Is this something we shouldn’t do?” McCartney asks in a voice-over, but neither he nor anyone else ever articulates exactly what the problem might be. Instead, the film answers unspoken objections by repeatedly swatting them down. McCartney imagines calling his old bandmate up — “Hey, John, would you like us to finish this last song of yours?” — and then supplies Lennon’s answer for him: “I’m telling you, I know the answer would’ve been ‘Yeah!’ He would have loved that!” John “would have loved” the approach, his son Sean concurs — “He was never shy to experiment with recording technology.” In the song’s music video, directed by Peter Jackson, a youthful Lennon is spliced into the “Now and Then” recording sessions: He does, indeed, look thrilled.

“We’ve all played on it,” McCartney says. “So it is a genuine Beatle recording.” On one hand, who is more qualified than McCartney to issue this edict of authenticity? On the other: Why did he feel the need?

Related Posts

In a Bold Rebuttal, Montoya Urges Ferrari to Take a New Direction: Replace Charles Leclerc With Lewis Hamilton and Bet Their Future on the British Superstar for a Shot at Glory. Does Ferrari Have the Courage to Make the Ultimate Driver Swap and Revive Their Championship Hopes?

In the Paddock: Ferrari’s Technical Crossroads and Hamilton’s Challenging 2025 Start As the Formula 1 circus unfolds in 2025, the mood in the Ferrari paddock is thick…

Sebastian Vettel’s Potential Comeback to Red Bull F1 Takes an Intriguing Turn as He Makes a Surprising £10,000 Investment, Sparking Speculation About His Future Role and What This Unexpected Move Could Mean for Both His Career and the Team’s Ambitions on the Formula 1 Grid.

Photo: © IMAGO F1 icon Sebastian Vettel has completed a milestone outside of motorsport after committing a £10,000 investment to the cause. The four-time champion has now completed a…

Tragedy Surrounds Michael Schumacher Case: Suspect Linked to Formula One Legend’s Stolen Medical Records Discovered Dead in Jail Cell Just Hours Before Court Hearing, Raising Questions About Security, Legal Procedure, and the Ongoing Battle for Privacy in High-Profile Investigations

Michael Schumacher’s medical records were stolen after his ski crash and a suspect was found hanged while in custody. A suspect accused of stealing and leaking Michael…

Intensifying Drama at McLaren: Zak Brown’s Shocking Confirmation Sets the Stage for a Fierce Teammate Rivalry, Raising Questions About the Team’s Future Unity and Performance Amid Mounting Internal Tensions. What Does This Mean for McLaren’s Ambitions and the Relationship Between Their Star Drivers Moving Forward?

Pastri Takes the Spanish Grand Prix – McLaren’s Glorious Nightmare Has Begun The 2024 Spanish Grand Prix in Barcelona wasn’t just another race—it was the moment McLaren…

Lewis Hamilton Addresses Canadian Grand Prix Developments, Surprising Ferrari and Shaking Up the Formula 1 Paddock with Unexpected Insights and Bold Statements About His Team’s Performance and Future Prospects. Fans and Experts Alike React to Hamilton’s Revealing Comments Ahead of a Crucial Race Weekend.

The Astonishing Results of Lewis Hamilton’s Spanking New Ferrari Floor Formula 1 is often described as a sport measured in tenths of a second but powered by…

In an Unprecedented Move That Sends Shockwaves Through Formula 1, Valtteri Bottas Joins Aston Martin as He Replaces Lance Stroll — Experts and Fans Alike React to This Dramatic Shake-Up That Promises to Reshape the Team’s Future and Bring New Excitement to the F1 Grid

Aston Martin Faces a Defining Moment: Lance Stroll’s Uncertain Future and the Search for a Silverstone Solution As the 2025 Formula 1 season approaches its mid-point, Aston…