The Golden Bachelor’s Peg Munson Isn’t The Best Match For Mel Owens

The Golden Bachelor season 2 lead Mel Owens has chosen Peg Munson and Cindy Cullers as his final two women, but he shouldn’t choose Peg in the end. Mel, a 66-year-old NFL player-turned-lawyer and divorced dad of two sons originally from Detroit, Michigan, had a rocky start to his season after he made ageist comments on a podcast, stating that he only wanted to date women aged 45 to 60.

However, The Golden Bachelor season 2 began with Mel apologizing to the 23 women in his cast, and he began to make some strong connections. As Mel heads to Antigua for his overnight Fantasy Suite dates, he’ll have to decide between his final two women: Cindy, a 60-year-old divorced retired biomedical engineer from Austin, Texas; and Peg, a 62-year-old divorced retired firefighter and bomb tech from Las Vegas, Nevada. However, Peg isn’t the best match for him.

Mel & Peg Haven’t Told Each Other ‘I Love You’ Yet

Image via Bachelor Nation

During her hometown date, Peg told her mother that she would say yes if Mel proposed to her, which was surprising considering that they hadn’t even said, “I love you,” to each other yet. However, Cindy told Mel that she was falling for him, as did Debbie Siebers, who received a hometown date, and Cheryl Steele, who was in Mel’s final five women.

In addition, Mel told Peg’s daughter, Dakota, that he wasn’t in love with her mom yet. He also admitted that he didn’t know if he could get there by the end of the journey. After the hometown date, Peg told host Jesse Palmer that she had feelings for Mel, but she was really nervous.

Peg said in her confessional that, although she thought that they’d fit well in each other’s lives, she didn’t know where she stood with him, which is a bad sign. Peg knew how she felt, but she wondered if he had a better connection with somebody else.

If Mel and Peg haven’t expressed feelings of love by now, then it’s likely that they never will. Mel should choose a woman who he’s really sure about, so that his relationship lasts. Also, if Peg doesn’t tell him how she feels, then he might not choose her because he doesn’t want to get hurt again. Mel has expressed on the show that he doesn’t take saying those three little words lightly because he’s only said them once, and he later got his heart broken during his divorce.

If Peg and Mel don’t tell each other that they’re in love with each other during her Fantasy Suite date, then there’s a good possibility that their relationship will end. In order for their romance to continue, they’re going to have to let down their walls and be honest about their feelings.

Mel & Peg Seem More Like Great Friends

Image via ABC

Peg and Mel had a wonderful time at the Orange County Fair during her one-on-one date. They played carnival games, made each other laugh, and danced together at the KC and The Sunshine Band concert. However, throughout the date, they seemed more like great friends than people who were on a date.

The same thing happened during their hometown date, when Peg introduced Mel to her family and her friends at her firehouse. While they had a great time, there was no romance. However, Peg told Mel that she wasn’t looking for the fireworks at this point in her life, but rather the fireplace, meaning that she wanted something that lasts, rather than something that burns hot right away, but then fizzles out. Mel agreed that he wanted the same thing.

Still, Mel and Peg might realize that, while they really enjoy each other’s company, their relationship is based more on friendship than anything romantic.

Peg’s Daughter Wasn’t Sure About Mel

Image via ABC

When Peg’s daughter, Dakota, met Mel, she was left unsatisfied with his answers about how he felt about her mom. In her confessional, Dakota admitted that she wished that he was more sure about his feelings. She told Peg that he was a nice man, but she was worried that Peg would let her guard down and then get hurt at the end of the journey.

However, Peg told her that if she didn’t take the risk, then she wouldn’t gain anything. She also insisted that she and Mel really had an authentic connection. Dakota told the cameras that she thought Peg had feelings for Mel, and she’d more than support their relationship. She felt that he seemed genuine and was a good match for Peg, but she hoped that he could continue to show her that he really was the person that Peg deserves.

Dakota seemed to have picked up on a vibe from Mel that made her doubt if he really loved Peg. This could be a problem down the line, especially if Dakota and Mel end up not getting along.

Although Dakota said that she’d accept Mel if he treated her mother right, if she eventually feels that he’s not doing that, then there could be conflict between them. Their conversation was a bit tense at points as Dakota tried to get Mel to open up about his feelings. However, Dakota was right: if Mel is unsure about Peg, then he should let her go.

Although Peg and Mel are building a connection, it seems more like a friendship than a romance. Both of them deserve to have a romantic relationship that’s deep and meaningful. Of course, this could develop during their overnight Fantasy Suite date, but, if it doesn’t, then they should end their relationship. Even though Mel and Peg really like each other, they don’t seem to be each other’s person. Mel shouldn’t choose Peg at the end of The Golden Bachelor season 2.

The Golden Bachelor airs Wednesdays at 9 p.m. EDT on ABC.