The conclusion of The Golden Bachelor Season 2 delivered a shocking twist: Bachelor Mel Owens chose finalist Peg Munson, but the traditional diamond engagement ring was notably replaced with a promise ring! The happy couple has since stepped forward to explain their unconventional ending, confirming that they are redefining the Golden Bachelor premise by taking things slow.

They openly revealed that their past divorces have made them deeply wary of rushing back down the aisle, a decision that reflects mature caution but has caused minor disappointment for their fans.
The Promise Ring: Wary of the Rush
Mel Owens, 66, and Peg Munson, 62, both divorced individuals, finished the season as a committed couple, but emphatically not engaged. Instead of a proposal, Mel gave Peg a sparkling promise ring, symbolizing their commitment to a future together, but at their own pace.
“I [wasn’t] going to get married right off the show,” Mel stated, noting the artificial, sped-up timeline of reality dating. “It’s like the saying: first comes love, then comes marriage. I don’t go from knowing a person to getting married.”
Sources confirm the two had an extensive, off-camera conversation during their Fantasy Suite date where they agreed on their unique path.
The Divorce Factor: Wary of the Aisle
The core reason for their cautious approach lies in the harsh lessons learned from their previous marriages. Mel’s first marriage ended in a messy, five-year legal battle that required him to pay a massive settlement, making him understandably hesitant about rushing into another contract. Peg, a retired firefighter and divorcee, echoed this sentiment, stating they are taking advantage of their “golden years” to write their own love story.
“Peg and I discussed the ring—I didn’t want to surprise her with something that she wasn’t expecting,” Mel clarified. “We’re doing it our way. I know it’s a bit unconventional, but it feels natural for us, and we went with it.”
Peg famously stated she was not looking for “fireworks” but for a “fireplace”—a slow burn for the rest of their lives—confirming they believe a mature, sustainable relationship is built over time, not on a dramatic finale proposal.
Minor Disappointment: Fans Wanted the Fairy Tale
While the majority of fans respect the couple’s mature decision, the lack of a traditional engagement or announced wedding date has caused a minor disappointment among viewers who invested in the fairy-tale expectation of the show.
Runner-up Cindy Cullers even self-eliminated from the show before the finale because she wanted a firm commitment and immediate marriage, highlighting the conflict between the show’s premise and Mel’s realistic intentions. Ultimately, Mel and Peg’s choice to prioritize an authentic, slow-burn romance over a fleeting engagement is seen as a sign of maturity, setting a new, realistic standard for the senior dating franchise.
Mel Owens and Peg Munson are still happily together and focusing on traveling and spending time with their families, proving a promise ring can be stronger than a rushed proposal.