“We can’t keep it in stock,” Beckham recently told Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live

PHOTO: SAMIR HUSSEIN/SAMIR HUSSEIN/WIREIMAGE; BERGDORF GOODMAN

We’ll tell you what we want, what we really really want: Victoria Beckham’s Satin Kajal Eyeliner. And so does everyone else.

During a recent episode of Watch What Happens Live, host Andy Cohen sat down with Beckham and brought up one of our PEOPLE’s Tested team’s findings. “Belle M. wants to know, ‘Why do you think your satin eyeliner landed on PEOPLE’s list of the top eyeliners of 2022? Is that your most proud of beauty product?'” he asked.

Beckham responded that her eyeliners are “incredible.” Posh Spice referred to her brand Victoria Beckham Beauty’s “strong focus on clean beauty,” and how “important” she thinks that is. “[The eyeliners] are amazing. We literally cannot keep them in stock.”

“Our Satin Kajal Liners are truly the best eyeliners out there — they are ultra-creamy, long wear, and come in the most flattering shades for a modern take on a smokey eye,” Beckham exclusively tells PEOPLE.

BERGDORF GOODMAN

Buy It! Victoria Beckham Beauty Satin Kajal Eyeliner, $28; bergdorfgoodman.com and violetgrey.com

 Calling all shoppers! Sign up to get hand-picked deals, celebrity fashion inspo, and more delivered by text message.

Rated PEOPLE Tested’s “best splurge” pick, the Satin Kajal Eyeliner has a smooth satin finish and dual ends for lining and blending. It’s available in a vibrant color range too, including nine shades such as olive, cocoa, bronze, and classic black. Considering this $28 eyeliner has a color pencil tip on one end and a blender on the other, it’s great for creating that “stayed out all night” smokiness and blurred edge liner that’s been a signature of Beckham’s look for years. And our tester loved that it was “so easy to apply,” a true standout feature when it comes to eyeliner.

“My favorite tip: You have 60 seconds to smudge before it sets, and once it sets, it won’t budge,” Beckham shares.

Whether you prefer winged, waterline, or blurred-out liner, the eyeliner will create a smooth and bold eye look for wherever the day takes you. It’s also completely waterproof, so it will stay locked in place from day to night. Plus, Victoria Beckham Beauty just launched a secondary eyeliner — Satin Kajal Jewel Liner — which has a shimmery finish as the perfect complement to any metallics you plan on wearing this holiday season.

“This holiday, I am obsessed with our new Jewel collection,” says Beckham. “They are full-on ’70s glam. We took our original Satin Kajal Liner formula (nothing can beat it) and added these incredibly luxurious pearls for high shine sparkle. It gives the look of glitter, without the mess or microplastics. My favourite shade is Sequin Green — it looks good on absolutely everyone.”

If you’re looking to try out something new to perfect your makeup looks ahead of the upcoming holiday party season, stock up on the Victoria Beckham Beauty Satin Kajal Eyeliner now while it’s still in stock.

See More from PEOPLE Shopping:

The 15 Best Mascaras of 2022 Our PEOPLE Tested Team Reviewed
I’m an Amazon Shopping Expert, and Everything I’m Buying at the Holiday Beauty Haul Sale Is on Major Sale
These Are the Affordable Drugstore Beauty Items That Bethenny Frankel Swears By

Do you love a good deal? Sign up for PEOPLE’s Shopping newsletter to stay up-to-date on the latest sales, plus celebrity fashion, home decor and more.

See More from PEOPLE Shopping

I Have Three Closets Full of Clothes, but I Can’t Stop Wearing the Divisive Shorts Celebs Are Returning To

Amazon Has an Under-the-Radar Section with Home Essentials to Host the Ultimate Brunch, and Prices Start at $7

I Swear by This Foundation That Was Once Used on Reba McEntire to Instantly Brighten My Skin, and It’s Just $14